Best Betrayal at House on the Hill Organizer (2023)

Betrayal at House on the Hill by Avalon Hill is a tabletop game full to the brim with mystery and intrigue. It’s suited for 3 to 6 players and tasks the group with exploring a haunted mansion while uncovering its secrets. Players can build the haunted house together room by room. Making the experience different every time the game is replayed. However, the ‘betrayal’ part of the game is also incredibly important too. One of the players will be secretly working to betray the party, and the rest of the group has to figure out who the traitor is in their midst. 

 It’s a board game that offers up tons of fun to groups that love to solve mysteries. It can be pretty complicated as well due to the many mechanics and monsters roaming about.  So it’s definitely a game that you’ll want to keep organized and well stored. This is where a high quality organizer comes into play, and it’s essential for games like these where you don’t want to lose any of the game pieces or miniatures. To make your life much easier, we’ve rounded up a few of the best organizer you can get right now at different price points. Let’s get straight into our guide for ‘The Best Organizers for Betrayal at House on the Hill’.

best betrayal at house on the hill organizer

Smonex Wood Organizer

The Smonex organizer for Betrayal at House on the Hill is my favorite all-in-one storage option, and it is far more convenient than the original plastic insert. It has room not only for the core box, but also includes space for the promo cards as well as the Widow’s Walk expansion. 

The wooden inserts are sturdy and well-made, with a card holder that has plenty of room for your character cards, tiles. the style of the tray is beautiful, with hand painted wood like something you might find on Etsy. There is also a vertical tile tray that makes room for your miniatures, and your rule-books fit nicely within. 

The removable trays are ideal for quick setup, as they provide a home for your character tokens and sleeved cards. Your character components are in good hands in this insert. 

The downsides here are few and far between. While it is not the cheapest option available, the Smonex organize is not as expensive as some custom items. The box also requires assembly, and you’ll need to bring your own glue. It’s a little more work than some of the other organizers, but we think it’s worth it. 


  • Well crafted
  • Great for quick setup
  • Holds expansions


  • Pricey
  • Assembly required

Check Availability on Amazon!

GeekOn Organizer

The first organizer that we’ve got for the list is one that’s both affordable and offers up plenty of storage space. We’ve gone for this organizer from GeekOn because it does a good job of giving you plenty of room, while keeping the price down. There are a few issues and things that could be better. For example, it isn’t the most protective thing out there, and it won’t do an amazing job with keeping your game pieces safe. But still, it’s an option that’s absolutely worth considering at the end of the day.

The first thing to make note of here is exactly how much storage space you’ll be able to use up. It can apparently hold up to 6 different board games, but in reality this number doesn’t mean all that much. Board games vary in size after all, so it’s hard to put an exact number there. It does have 16 different pockets though, and they’re a decent size too. You shouldn’t be short of space for a few games that’s for sure. Each pocket is made out of a mesh material and sealable with Velcro.

The bag itself is made out of a tough nylon that can withstand a fair amount of damage. Because this is a soft-shell case though, it won’t protect from harsh knocks or falls. Generally speaking, the construction of the organizer is really solid. However, there are a few places that it does fall short in. The lack of a carrying handle is a big omission that makes transporting the case a much bigger hassle than it needs to be. Plus, the interior of the case does look a little messy due to the looseness of the nylon. It’s great as an affordable option though, and it should last a while if taken care of. 


  • Affordable
  • Lightweight
  • Lots of space


  • No carrying handle
  • Interior build quality could improve

Check Availability on Amazon!

Hermitshell Organizer

For our next organizer, we’ve gone for a case that offers up rugged protection for Betrayal at House on the Hill. This case from Hermitshell is actually specifically designed for the game and does its job perfectly. Obviously since it’s designed to only work for this one game, it’s not really suitable for storing more than one game at a time. But this is a perfect choice for those that are only planning on taking Betrayal at House on the Hill away with them. It offers a compact storage solution for the game, while giving it plenty of protection from the elements. 

 This case has a hard shell design, meaning that it can take more than a few knocks and be just fine. Even if you bang it on something, drop it accidentally, or splash water all over it, the game inside should be just fine. Which is exactly what you want a case like this to do; protect the pieces inside from harm. The inside of the case is also appropriately padded so that things can’t move around too much on the go. There are even straps that can be pulled over the playing cards, so they remain still and don’t end up causing a mess inside the organizer. Underneath the lid, there’s a large mesh pocket for the play mat. It’s big enough to also hold a few pens and pencils too if you want to store them in there as well.

The general build quality here is really impressive, with the whole package seeming pretty high quality. The price is also fairly affordable too, so it won’t break the bank or anything like that. The lack of extra storage space is sure to be a pain for some, but for big fans of  Betrayal at House on the Hill, it’s a must-buy.


  • Affordable
  • Strong & durable
  • Very portable


  • Only fits one game
  • Plain

Check Availability on Amazon!

See Also: The Best Dominion Organizer

Comecase Organizer

Next up, we’ve got an organizer that offers up lots of storage space inside a protective case that can take more than a few beatings. This Comecase organizer does have a few issues here and there as well, but as long as you know what you’re getting, you shouldn’t be surprised. The first major thing to note is that this case is geared more towards card games and as such it doesn’t have things like sealable pockets for smaller game pieces. This is a problem that can be pretty easily dealt with though, and after a bit of extra preparation, this case can perform just as well as any other board game organizer.

In terms of its actual storage space, it can fit around 3000 standard sized cards. Obviously, that’s a little difficult to directly compare to the space needed for several board games. But for rough estimates, you’ll probably be able to fit up to 2 to 3 board games in the case. Keeping the pieces separated is also made easier thanks to the dividers that come with the case, totaling to 7. Now, since there aren’t any sealable pockets here, you’re going to need a solution to keeping your pieces organized even further.

The best thing to get in this situation are small plastic bags that you can use to store things like dice and counters. Keeping these pieces in small bags will not only solve the biggest problem this case has, but it’ll also allow you to pack those pieces in tightly and save even more space as a result. The case is made out of a hardshell material that should be able to protect the contents against most hazards as well. So all in all, this is a great case that requires a little more effort to work well as a board game organizer. 


  • Great build quality
  • Durable & strong
  • Portable


  • Designed for card games only
  • Limited space

Check Availability on Amazon!

TowerRex Organizer

For the next option, we’ve gone for something that should appeal to huge fans of Betrayal at House on the Hill. What we have here, are inserts for the original box of the game. These inserts are designed to fit perfectly inside the box and provide a much sturdier way of organizing the game. It offers up the perfect amount of room that you’d need for the game’s board pieces while also perfectly matching its aesthetics. Now this style of organizer does have its share of drawbacks that we’ll get into in a second. But this is definitely an organizer that big fans of the game should consider getting.

The TowerRex inserts are made out of a light wood material that don’t add too much weight to the overall game. They look great and have lots of cool little details all over. But beyond that, these inserts are pretty self-explanatory beyond a handful of potential problems. The first thing that we’ll get into here is the biggest issue facing an organizer like this. Since the inserts are dependent on the original box, you’re basically stuck to using that box. Meaning that you won’t have the benefits of a more portable organizer that you can take anywhere and everywhere. You’re locked into using the original box that the game came with and, while that may not be an issue for everyone, it does severely limit where you can go with the game.

The other thing is that these inserts will require some self-assembly with wood glue. It’s not the hardest thing to assemble in the world as the manufacturing on these is fine, but it could be annoying for those who aren’t gifted with DIY skills. But if you can get past those issues, this really is a great way to organize your edition of Betrayal at House on the Hill. While it is a little pricey, it definitely something that big fans of the game should check out. 


  • Durable
  • Easy organization
  • Tons of useful details


  • LImited to the original box
  • Assembly required

Check Availability on Amazon!

Buying Guide

 If you’ve gotten to this point in the list and want to know even more about organizers, that’s perfect! In this section we’ve got a few tips to share regarding shopping for the best organizer. 

What to look for in an organizer

 Organizers for tabletop games come in all different shapes and sizes. You can get organizers that simply make the process of unboxing your game easier, so that you can get to playing a lot quicker. And you can get organizers that perfectly sort your game, so you have a much easier time when putting stuff away. Either way, if you’re getting an organizer you can be sure that it’ll help your tabletop experience tenfold. The kind of organizer you’ll want will depend on your tastes though. If you’re the sort that tends to just get whatever works, you probably won’t really care about how it looks or what it’s made from. As long as it’s made out of a durable material it’ll do the job well. 

But if you’re someone who cares more about aesthetics then there’s a lot out there for you. You can find a lot of organizers that are themed around the games that they’re made for, like box inserts. These are usually a little more expensive but definitely worth the purchase if you’re into that kind of thing. These kinds of organizers are often made out of a wood composite material that is lightweight and looks great. Though remember that these can sometimes be a little pricey too. You can also find organizers that can store tons of different board games at once. These can widely vary in price, going for as cheap as $25 all the way up to $100 or above. So really it’ll depend on what you value more in your tabletop accessories and how much you’re willing to spend. 

Reliable brands you should stick with

There are tons of tabletop brands who you can buy your accessories from. And there are certainly some that are better than others. So if you’re going to be buying some tabletop accessories, make sure you’re buying them from the right company! Below is a list of some of the brands that we would recommend you buy your Betrayal at House on the Hill  organizers from.

  • Folded Space
  • The Broken Token
  • Smonex
  • TowerRex

Obviously these aren’t the only good brands out there for this kind of stuff. But, if you want to be safer in your purchase, you should stick with these brands. Stay away from cheaper brands and companies, since these tend to be of lesser quality than more expensive options. With things like this you really do get what you pay for, so make sure to not go cheaper unless you’re sure about what you’re buying. 


  • If you’ve got any tabletop friends, check to see if they have any recommendations for what kind of organizer would be the best one to get. They may know about a great brand that they can personally recommend to you.
  • Make sure you double-check the reviews of whatever you are buying to make sure you know exactly what you’re getting. You can potentially save yourself some money by doing this.
  • Try and find organizers that are designed to work specifically for the game you intend to play. Organizers that have a more specific design can cater to the needs of certain games far better than larger, more general cases.
  • If you’re buying inserts, make sure they fit inside the Betrayal at House on the Hill  box. Most organizers work as inserts for the original box of the game. You can sometimes find organizers that come with their own box for the game, but they’re rarer and typically more expensive. 
  • Most box inserts will require some form of self-assembly, so make sure that you’re prepared for that. You can ask someone who is good at putting these sorts of things together for some help too.
  • Some of the most common kinds of materials for inserts are Evacore and Wood. These are dependable materials that are strong and light, and they work great for organizers. But you can also find some other organizers that are made from cardboard or plastic. So look around and find the material that’s right for you. 


That was our list for ‘The Best Betrayal at House on the Hill Organizers in 2022’. If it helped you out with finding your next board game organizer, be sure to let us know in the comments below. From small monster tokens to card trays, these options have room for everything. If you’re anything like me, you’ll appreciate playing the game directly out of the storage box instead of a bunch of baggies. We take great pride in reviewing each third-party accessory for the games we love.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.